Immaculate Conception
 

Status: Active, Catholic

Founded: 1869

Front & Allen Streets
Philadelphia, PA 19123

http://archphila.org/parishes/7175.htm

 
Where Is It?


Front & Allen Streets, which puts it under I-95 in Northern Liberties. No, seriously.

The Skinny


As you might have guessed, the Project gets a decent amount of e-mail. Most of it consists of glowing comments about my genius, although there are the occasional malcontents who feel I’ve been too harsh on their beloved parish. (At least no one has called me unmentionable names. Whatever faults religious people might have, courtesy isn’t usually one of them.)

A lot of times, though, people suggest parishes that absolutely require my immediate attention. One such parish is Northern Liberties’ Immaculate Conception. Not to be confused with Immaculate Conception, Immaculate Conception BVM, Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception, Ukranian Catholic Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception, and a shrine that used to be known as the Public Chapel of the Immaculate Conception.

Oh yes, the Immaculate Inception at work.

This, the final piece of the Immaculate puzzle, is notable because it’s sort of a casualty of the lovely little road known as I-95. The Project once noted that St. Adalbert was prominent because it sat right off the west side of I-95. That’s still true, albeit by several blocks. But if you thought Adalbert was close, hold on to your pews. Immaculate Conception is so close that it is literally, seriously right next to and under I-95 (and the Market-Frankford El, as well). You could stand on the side of the road and spit on the church.

Certainly this wasn’t the plan when they built the church, as evidenced by this lovely historic artist’s rendering, circa 1901:

Nice, eh? If only they had known that their descendents would eventually build a highway on top of the thing, they might have done things a little differently.

As it stands, this Immaculate is probably the least impressive of the bunch. That’s not as much of an insult as it sounds, but it’s just up against some really impressive competition. There’s some good stuff here; the red-brick and white-trim exterior is very lovely, and inside, the Italian-Renaissance décor is smart and colorful, if not particularly overwhelming. The stained-glass windows, main altar and ceramic-colored organ are the highlights here. The paintwork, including the murals, doesn’t particularly excite, but at least they had the good sense to make the base color cream instead of white.

LOOK FOR IT: The funky ceiling rafters, which are truly unlike anything we’ve seen before.

DON’T BOTHER LOOKING FOR IT: The cute little spire that appears in the artist’s rendering; it’s long gone. Or perhaps it never existed; some old parishioners maintain that it was never installed. (Thanks to Bill for the heads-up.)

Oh, and the church has oddly curved sides, instead of the typical boxy shape of most Italian-Renaissance. Again, kind of unique.

All in all, it’s pretty good. It doesn’t have the massive size, or the elite ornamentation, or the soaring columns, or the expansive dome, or the…whatever Jenkintown has going for it. But it’s tasteful and nice in its own understated way. It sort of reminds me of the “old(e)” parishes, like Augustine or Michael. It doesn’t punch you in the mouth, but it wins your affections nonetheless.

Size Rating: 7 out of 10

Ornamentation Rating: 7.5 out of 10

Overall Design Rating: 7.5 out of 10 crosses

How's It Doing?


Not very well, but what else do you expect from a smaller parish that was virtually bludgeoned out of existence by I-95 and the El? Their construction displaced a lot of parishioners; as a result, the school closed and the parish has limped along ever since. It’s still there, but almost an afterthought. Out of sight, out of mind, you might say.

Maybe that’s why the Archdiocese hasn’t closed it; even they don’t remember it’s still around. The numbers simply defy logic; they have a registered population of under 200 and an average attendance of only 55. Hell, even poor Most Blessed Sacrament had more than that. And while Immaculate Conception isn’t officially listed as a Dead Parish Walking, everything is administered by Rev. Bill Ayres, the pastor at neighboring St. Michael, who gets the fortune of pulling double-duty to cover Immaculate’s one weekly mass.

Don’t get me wrong; I hate to see any parish close. But the numbers are just atrocious, the parish doesn’t have its own priest and, frankly, it’s not particularly needed. I mean, this isn’t a church-starved area. You’re right near the aforementioned St. Michael and St. Peter the Apostle, as well as the Fishtown parishes, Holy Name and St. Laurentius.

I’d love to see Immaculate survive, but I don’t see how the Archdiocese can continue to operate a parish that seems mostly superfluous. They’ve closed far healthier parishes than this. Expect a Twinning at best, and at worst, well….

Emergency Rating: …we might have a flatliner

Travel Tidbits


Northern Liberties is incredibly easy to get to via I-95, and the area’s recent renaissance has made it pretty carefree to traverse. (The rebirth hasn’t helped this parish, but that’s another matter.)

The church supposedly has a lot (although I somehow missed it), but you may still need to street park. The Project actually ended up parked under I-95 itself, which was, I won’t lie, a little unnerving. Still, I take what I can get.

Safety Rating: 8.5 out of 10 tire irons

Interesting Note


You know what makes mass great? Having the El zoom by and rattle the windows every 10-15 minutes or so. Yeah!

The Final Word


Not as awe-inspiring as some people make it out to be, but not a bad trip. If you have any designs on seeing it, however, I wouldn’t dally.


 


© 2008 Philadelphia Church Project